A federal judge rejected the government’s attempt to settle with Guidant Corporation over its sale of potentially flawed heart defibrillators. The government had reached a plea agreement in which the company would have pled guilty to two misdemeanors and paid a $296 million fine for failing to alert doctors and patients about the possibly fatal defects. But U.S. District Court Judge Donovan W. Frank ruled that the agreement’s provisions were “not in the best interest of justice and do not serve the public’s interest because they do not adequately address Guidant’s history and the criminal conduct at issue,” The New York Times reports.
Judge Frank said that prosecutors should have sought probation for Guidant and its parent, Boston Scientific. Probation would have required the companies to take certain steps, like helping to rebuild public confidence in the safety of heart devices, in addition to paying a fine.
Two doctors who helped bring to light problems with the heart devices had urged the judge to reject the plea bargain.
Related:Doctors Urge Judge to Reject Plea Bargain in Guidant Case
Justice Department: Cardiac Device Maker Failed to Report Safety Problems
Cardio Implant Maker Pleads Guilty for Not Reporting Safety Problems


